Email strategy

Emails aren't read, they're scanned: how to build a newsletter layout that gets clicks

by Giorgio Terenziani · Updated on 2026-11-19 · 9 min read
Layout of an ecommerce newsletter seen from top to bottom: headline, image, primary button, products and footer, with the path of the eye down to the click

In short

  • An ecommerce newsletter should be built for people who scan it: a headline in live text, one primary button per screen and seven blocks in an order that leads from attention to the click.
  • It has to hold up when images don't load, in dark mode and when the brand font is replaced by the fallback, as happens in Gmail on the web.
  • Judge the layout by clicks and the click map, not by opens. And the topic matters more than the structure: an email with no reason to visit the site can't be saved by a button.

An effective ecommerce newsletter is built for people who scan it, not for people who read it: a headline that says it all in live text, one primary button per screen and seven blocks in an order that leads from attention to the click. The layout decides how many people reach your site; the topic decides whether they have a reason to go. We'll show it with a made-up store and with the real numbers of an Italian footwear store we work with. This article is about how to lay the newsletter out; what to write in it is covered in ecommerce newsletter ideas.

How do you structure an effective newsletter for an ecommerce store?

Start with how people look at it. In Nielsen Norman Group's tests, 79% of users scanned new pages and only 16% read them word by word. That research dates from 1997, but in 2017 the same institute found the F-shaped reading pattern again, on mobile too: the first lines, and the first words of each line, get almost all the attention.

For a newsletter, that means three things:

  1. The message goes at the top. After two seconds, people should know what it's about and where to click.
  2. Each block has one job. If a block does three things, people who scan see none of them.
  3. Each block starts with the words that matter. "New in: twelve hand-glazed pieces" works; "We're delighted to announce that..." doesn't.

Try AchillesAI for free: it optimizes the copy of your emails continuously and automatically.

Try it for free

Visual hierarchy: size, contrast, density

People who scan don't choose what to read: the layout chooses for them, with three levers.

  • Size and weight. A large, bold headline gets read first. If everything is big, nothing is.
  • Contrast. Color guides the eye to the button, in dark mode too.
  • Density. Small, dense text looks secondary, and only people who are already interested read it. Paragraphs of two or three lines, no walls of text.

One primary button per screen

Level What it's for How many
Primary The action the newsletter exists for One per screen
Secondary The alternative for people the primary doesn't convince One, with less visual weight
Tertiary Categories, guides, social More than one is fine, as text links
Unsubscribe Leaving the list Always visible at the bottom, never hidden

Two identical buttons on the same screen force people to choose, and people who scan often don't. The button text says what happens next: "See the collection", never "Click here". A hidden unsubscribe link keeps no one: people who can't find it mark the email as spam, and that weighs on every send, as we explain in why emails go to spam.

The anatomy of a newsletter in seven blocks

Take a made-up tableware ceramics store announcing its autumn collection.

Layout of a newsletter in seven blocks, from header to footer, with the job of each one; the first screen ends after the primary button

The seven blocks of a newsletter and the job of each one. Generic layout, without store or product names.
Block Job In the example
1. Header Make the sender recognizable, offer a shortcut Logo and four links: Plates, Mugs, New in, Gifts
2. Opening Say it all at a glance Photo of the table; headline "Autumn has arrived at the table" in live text
3. Copy and primary button Give the reason and the action Three lines on the colors of the season; button "See the collection"
4. Collection Show the choice without making people read "Three pieces to start with": three photos and the secondary button "All new arrivals"
5. Featured products Go deeper for people who are interested Same structure for every piece: name, photo, one sentence, link
6. Closing Leave one idea of the brand "No two pieces are alike: that's how we work"
7. Footer Reassure and offer services Returns, payments, workshop, social, contact, unsubscribe

Why this order. Interest drops as people scroll, so whatever leads to the click sits on the first screen. People who keep going find the overview first, then the details, which only interested readers read. The footer answers the doubts that come last: returns, shipping, payments. And the same structure for every product is quicker to scan.

The copy inside the blocks needs a writing framework: we cover that in AIDA, PAS or FAB: which copywriting framework to use in emails.

Copy that holds up without images, in dark mode and with any font

Images may not load. Headline, subheading and button go in live text, not inside the image: if the image is blocked, the message survives. Every image gets alt text.

Dark mode changes colors. According to Litmus's guide, email clients behave in three ways: some change nothing, some invert only light backgrounds, some invert everything. In Litmus data from 2022, an average of 35% of tracked opens happened in dark mode. The precautions: logo as a transparent PNG with a light outline, no thin fonts, and a test in the main clients before important sends.

Your website font doesn't always arrive. According to Klaviyo, custom fonts work in Apple Mail and iOS Mail but not in Gmail (at least the web version) and Yahoo, where the fallback shows up; according to Can I email, Outlook for Windows ignores fonts loaded from an external server. In Litmus data for July 2026, Gmail and desktop Outlook (Windows and Mac) together account for about one open in three (27.03% and 5.83%). Pick a fallback font close to yours.

The case: what a real newsletter tells you

The Italian footwear store we work with sells handmade women's shoes in the premium segment. This is its new collection newsletter from early October 2026.

From send to order: about 25,400 emails delivered, 8,796 opens, 1,030 clicks, 19 orders and €4,657 in revenue

From send to order: the footwear store's new collection newsletter. Click rate is calculated on all recipients.
  • About 25,400 emails delivered.
  • Opens at 34.60%. An inflated number: Apple Mail Privacy Protection records opens nobody made, and Klaviyo says it can't tell them apart from real ones.
  • Clicks at 4.05%: 1,030 people. Click rate is calculated on all recipients, not on those who opened. On those recorded as openers it would be about 11.7%.
  • 19 orders, €4,657 in attributed revenue, €0.18 per recipient. About 1.8% of the people who clicked bought.

Data read three days after sending: orders and revenue may still grow.

The newsletter's job ends at the click. The 4.05% is above the average of the store's 42 campaigns over the past twelve months (3.56%); the rest is down to the product page, price and timing. To judge the structure, look at clicks; to judge the campaign, look at orders and revenue per recipient.

The topic matters more than the layout

In the same store, in the twelve months to October 10, 2026, four types of newsletter have enough sends for a comparison.

Click rate and orders per campaign by newsletter type: new arrivals, time-limited promotions, seasonal sales and social livestream announcements

Click rate and average orders per campaign, by newsletter type, in the footwear store. Samples of 4 to 16 campaigns.
Type Campaigns Click rate Orders per campaign
New arrivals (collections, new in) 16 3.92% 13.4
Time-limited promotions 16 3.35% 21.6
Seasonal sales 5 4.83% 25.8
Social livestream announcements 4 1.35% 8.5

Social livestream announcements have a click rate of 1.35%, less than half that of the other types. That isn't a layout problem: the action they ask for happens on social media, and the newsletter gives no reason to visit the site. When the topic doesn't lead to the site, no button can save it. And new arrivals get more clicks than promotions but bring fewer orders: people browsing the collection often don't buy right away.

Two caveats: these are 4 to 16 campaigns per type, not a controlled test, and promotions fall on dates like Black Friday. The year's only content-only email is left out: one send isn't enough.

The click map: how to tell if your newsletter gets read to the end

Almost every platform shows where people click inside the email: it's the most direct tool for judging the structure.

Unique clicks per link in the new collection newsletter: 481 on the first button, 289 on the second one further down, 33 to 93 on each of the six product cards, 12 on the logo

Unique clicks per link in the early October newsletter. Store data, product names hidden.

In the early October newsletter, the two buttons to the collection get about two clicks in three: 481 people on the first, 289 on the second, further down. The second button still drawing 289 people tells you the email gets scrolled, not just glanced at the top. The six product cards get fewer clicks than the buttons, 33 to 93 each, but every one of them gets some. We don't know the exact position of each block and there was no test: these numbers describe one send, not a rule.

That's why it pays to compare the maps of several sends with the same structure: one map describes a newsletter; three maps describe your list.

The most common mistakes

  • Three identical buttons on the first screen, perhaps saying "Click here".
  • A custom font without a chosen fallback. In Gmail on the web, your text changes look.
  • Judging the structure by opens. With Apple Mail the number is inflated: look at clicks.
  • A hidden unsubscribe link. It turns into a spam complaint.

Frequently asked questions

How many buttons should I put in a newsletter?

One primary button per screen, meaning each part you can see without scrolling, plus at most one secondary button with less visual weight. Links to categories and social can be more numerous, as plain text links. Two identical buttons side by side force people to choose, and people who scan often don't.

Is it better to build a newsletter entirely from images, or with text?

Images to show the products, live text for everything people need to understand and click: headline, subheading, button. If the image doesn't load or gets blocked, an email made only of images is empty. Every image also needs alt text that says what it shows.

How do I know if my newsletter looks right in dark mode?

Test it before sending in the email clients your subscribers use, because they behave differently: some don't change colors, some invert only light backgrounds, some invert everything. The weak spots are the logo, thin text and dark icons on transparent backgrounds.

What is a good click rate for a newsletter?

The most useful benchmark is your own list's history, always calculated the same way: in Klaviyo the click rate is based on people who received the email, not on those who opened it. In an Italian footwear store we work with, the average across 42 campaigns in twelve months was 3.56%, and the new collection newsletter in early October hit 4.05%.

Can I use my website's font in my newsletter?

Yes, but not everyone will see it. According to Klaviyo, Gmail and Yahoo don't load custom fonts and show the fallback instead, and according to Can I email, Outlook for Windows ignores fonts loaded from an external server. Pick a fallback font close to yours and check that the email works with it too.

Sources

newsletternewsletter layoutemail designcall to actiondark modeclick rateecommerce
Giorgio Terenziani
Giorgio Terenziani
Co-founder of AchillesAI · Performance Marketing & Creative Strategist

Performance marketer since 2015, expert in Meta and Google. Combines creative strategy, content production and data analysis with a results-driven approach.

Read in: itenfresde

Recover more sales, automatically

AchillesAI generates and optimizes recovery emails with AI, integrating with your existing tools.

Discover AchillesAI